I don't really know for sure, but since no one else has answered, I'll give this a shot. You said the switch was new, so someone had to have installed it recently. So since it does work (somewhat) and it works fine going the other way, I would say check the wiring and the connection. Maybe upon installation of the new switch something was not connected as well as it should have been.

__________________
'86 420SE Euro
904 Midnight Blue, Gray Velour
Dad bought it new, now I own it.

"A Mercedes-Benz is like a fine wine, it only gets better with age."