Noise now, the thing fully collapsed. The car had the same mount from about '04 to sometime in '11 I think, would have to check records. Nothing changed in that time frame under the car, all exhaust mounts are in place. I guess I purchased this car around '06/7.
The Meyle HD is garbage as is the Uro (but the Uro lasted longer shockingly), I will try my luck with another OE mount. I have had more than one part that was new in the box fail, just part of life due to mass production.
My driver side too was replaced when the head was off, that is Meyle. Not sure if I have done the trans mount recently or not.