View Single Post
  #24  
Old 11-05-2013, 02:13 PM
mach4's Avatar
mach4 mach4 is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: San Diego County, CA
Posts: 2,736
Diesel Fuel Lubricity Additives Study Results

I've attached a .pdf version of the study results - link.

It would be nice to have an updated set of test results, but I'm certain that these tests are not cheap to have performed by a certified lab.

Just to toss some additional data into the hopper for consideration (and probably to muddy the waters a bit), here's a nugget of data from the data sheet of the FPPF Lubricity plus Fuel Power product referenced in the original post.



This test appears to be the same one used by Spicer.

Comparison of results
HTML Code:
Tester                     Base Fuel HFRR         Treated HFFR        Net
Spicer *                      636                      675           39 worse
Research Institute            425                      260           165 better
* actual lab not disclosed

Recommended standards
US - no greater than 520 microns
Engine Manufacturers Association - no greater than 460 microns

So the base fuel for the FPPF test exceeded the recommended standards to begin with.

The question that remains unanswered in all this is, Why would the results get worse in one case and better in the other?

Pending other data, the bottom line for me personally is to go back to 2-stroke oil but at a 200:1 ratio. As has been pointed out, experience shows little documented evidence of problems with the MB IP using ULSD, so for me the use of an additive is really just cheap insurance.

I've done a significant amount of research and there appears to be no updated data, and even data on current HFRR testing of current fuels is not readily available.
Attached Thumbnails
Beginning To Rethink the Idea of 2 Stroke Oil as a Fuel Additive-fppf1.jpg  
Attached Files
File Type: pdf Diesel fuel additive version 3.pdf (130.7 KB, 54 views)
__________________
Current Stable
  • 380SL (diesel)
  • Corvette C5
  • Manx
  • Baja Bug
  • F350 Powerstroke
  • Auburn Boattail Speedster replica
Reply With Quote