1) the paint is kind of dull (not shiny)
2) it isn't matching the rest of the body color
3) the paint peeled off using a finger nail while trying to check a bad spot
...ahem...this is NOT the best they can do...if that is the BEST they can do, they should not even BE in business...tell the manager the paint job is ridiculous...show him the problems that you listed...ANY shop can plainly see that the job was not properly done...obviously, DO NOT pay them the second half...the job was not completed to your satisfaction...tell the manager to FIX it, or if they are incapable of doin' a better job, then give back your money, and you will find another bodyshop to do it properly...if not, they can talk to your lawyer...
1995 black pearl/black Mercedes-Benz E420