My car insurance companies (AAA, State Farm and USAA over the years) all maintained that they were obligated to pay until the car is "in the condition as prior to the damage". I held them to this a couple of times when I had to have the hood reshot (vandalism) and a door completely replaced (careless neighbor). Both times the paint and trim did not match and they had to do the hood three times before it matched well enough that I couldn't tell. YOu might want to complain/ask.