Can you replace solenoid without removing starter?

I deffinately would not. To get the solenoid to unhooh from the starter drive fork, you need to pull the fork pivot bolt out. You would spend twice the time trying to change it "in frame".

__________________
My Truck.. 2007 DODGE, 5.9 Cummins, 6spd stick, 4X4. My car..1977 240D, OTHER WHEELS...1955 VW Oval window bug, European Delivery (Holland) with a 1700cc, 2 barrel, Porsche drum brakes. 1939 WILLYS Pick-up. 1967 Triumph 200cc Tiger Cub. 1976 Honda 550F 4cyl Motor Cycle.