PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/)
-   Diesel Discussion (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/)
-   -   What in particular causes vacuum pump failure? (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/204187-what-particular-causes-vacuum-pump-failure.html)

GRIESL 03-16-2008 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by t walgamuth (Post 1794209)
The 617 pumps can fail. ON mine it did make noise and the vac system stopped working too before the pump came apart with catastrophic results. I heard the noise but when I took it to the dealer to hear it of course it miraculously healed itself. I knew something was up but had no clue such a catastrophic result was possible. The system went into comlete melt down on a trip to st louis halfway home and I was about 30 miles form home when it crapped.

That was fifteen years ago or more long before this excellent resource existed.

Tom W

Can you please describe "catastrophic?" The condition of my VP seems OK, but I don't know if it's ever been rebuilt or replaced. Perhaps that should be added to my todo list. Thanks.

Stevo 03-16-2008 11:09 AM

[QUOTE=Kevin Johnson;1794207]Hi,

I found a later pump in a trip to the wrecking yard and decided to use it to replace my older pump with unknown but probably very high mileage.

I swapped an "early" pump on to a "later" 240D engine, you also have too swap the air cleaner and the vacuum line to the brake booster.

Diesel911 03-16-2008 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GRIESL (Post 1794239)
Can you please describe "catastrophic?" The condition of my VP seems OK, but I don't know if it's ever been rebuilt or replaced. Perhaps that should be added to my todo list. Thanks.

Boy I had forgotten that I even started this thread. I started the thread as I had read quite a few threads on how the Vacuum Pump had failed and pieces of it fell into the timing chain area and caused the timing chain to fail (even break, the catastrophic part). One of the members Stevo believed the Vacuum Pump failure was caused in his case by the IP pump Timer (this is the unit that drives the IP and advances the timing on the IP). He said his had too much end play (moved back and fourth too much).
Because of all of this I decided to pull off my Vacuum Pump and take a look. After removal a visual inspection I could not see any thing that looked like it was badly worn or ready to fall apart and I put it back on. (I was inspection the arm, linkage and roller that drives the vacuum pump piston; this is the part that is inside the engine.)
If something goes wrong on the other end of the pump the part with the valves in it the pump will just stop producing vacuum and you will loose your power brakes and will not be able to shutoff the engine (you will have to open the hood and push the manual shutoff by the valve cover).
The pump is not hard to get off; I did have to loosen the Power Steering Pump and remove the belt from the Power Steering Pulley in order to get the V Pump off.
I will PM you some additional information.

Stevo 03-16-2008 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diesel911 (Post 1794292)
Boy I had forgotten that I even started this thread. I started the thread as I had read quite a few threads on how the Vacuum Pump had failed and pieces of it fell into the timing chain area and caused the timing chain to fail (even break, the catastrophic part). One of the members Stevo believed the Vacuum Pump failure was caused in his case by the IP pump Timer (this is the unit that drives the IP and advances the timing on the IP). He said his had too much end play (moved back and fourth too much).
Because of all of this I decided to pull off my Vacuum Pump and take a look. After removal a visual inspection I could not see any thing that looked like it was badly worn or ready to fall apart and I put it back on. (I was inspection the arm, linkage and roller that drives the vacuum pump piston; this is the part that is inside the engine.)
If something goes wrong on the other end of the pump the part with the valves in it the pump will just stop producing vacuum and you will loose your power brakes and will not be able to shutoff the engine (you will have to open the hood and push the manual shutoff by the valve cover).
The pump is not hard to get off; I did have to loosen the Power Steering Pump and remove the belt from the Power Steering Pulley in order to get the V Pump off.
I will PM you some additional information.

Another member "Craig" also had his VP fail due too way too much end play in the timing device. (with catastrophic results). I had my engine out and on the stand but pulling that timing device to get to the brass bushing would be a PIA with the engine in the car, The T chain doesn't want to let it go.:mad:

t walgamuth 03-16-2008 11:45 AM

I don't really know what caused my failure but I suppose the bearings failed and the pump continued to work with the parts simply rubbing on each other until one wore in half.

Then that part fell into the cam chain and broke the cam chain and the pistons collided with the stationary open valves pushing them up breaking the cam and cam towers.

Then fixing just the broken stuff was going to be a couple of grand and doing the whole motor was only another three or so so I did that too.

If it happened today with what I know about the bottom end of a benz motor I would not do the bottom end, just a valve job and repair the damage and lite it off!

Tom W

Craig 03-16-2008 11:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stevo (Post 1794297)
Another member "Craig" also had his VP fail due too way too much end play in the timing device. (with catastrophic results). I had my engine out and on the stand but pulling that timing device to get to the brass bushing would be a PIA with the engine in the car, The T chain doesn't want to let it go.:mad:

I don't know if the end play actually caused the pump failure, but there was too much end play and the bushing was well worn. My indy replaced it in the car, a giant PITA from what I saw. To get the timing chain out of the way you have to move the cain guide, which requires removing a VERY tight pin that is pressed into the block. My indy spent the better part of two days working on mine.

Stevo 03-16-2008 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 1794318)
I don't know if the end play actually caused the pump failure, but there was too much end play and the bushing was well worn. My indy replaced it in the car, a giant PITA from what I saw. To get the timing chain out of the way you have to move the cain guide, which requires removing a VERY tight pin that is pressed into the block. My indy spent the better part of two days working on mine.

I had to remove the timing device on an engine I had just rebuilt because if forgot to replace the main oil gallery end plug :o, plug was in back of the T/D:eek: The "pin" was easy, getting the T/D out with the chain around it, another matter, I stuck a bunch of screw drivers and other "pointy' tools in there to hold the chain away, not fun:(

Diesel911 03-16-2008 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 1794318)
I don't know if the end play actually caused the pump failure, but there was too much end play and the bushing was well worn. My indy replaced it in the car, a giant PITA from what I saw. To get the timing chain out of the way you have to move the cain guide, which requires removing a VERY tight pin that is pressed into the block. My indy spent the better part of two days working on mine.

How many miles were on the engine when you found out that the Timer bushing was worn out?

Diesel911 03-16-2008 06:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stevo (Post 1794297)
Another member "Craig" also had his VP fail due too way too much end play in the timing device. (with catastrophic results). I had my engine out and on the stand but pulling that timing device to get to the brass bushing would be a PIA with the engine in the car, The T chain doesn't want to let it go.:mad:

How many miles were on the engine when you found that the Timer bushing was worn out?

Diesel911 03-16-2008 06:46 PM

Since the Vacuum pump is not so hard to remove I figure maybe ounce a year or so I would take a look at it.

Craig 03-16-2008 07:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diesel911 (Post 1794661)
How many miles were on the engine when you found that the Timer bushing was worn out?

As I recall it was about 380 - 390K. I do remember it was before I turned over 400K. It sounded just like a bad vacuum pump, but the sound didn't go away when the pump was replaced. The sprocket behind the IP/vacuum pump was banging around too much, it's only supposed to have about 1 mm of axially movement.

Hatterasguy 03-16-2008 07:53 PM

So it was just worn out, at almost 400k miles it had a lot of time on it.

Diesel911 03-20-2008 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hatterasguy (Post 1794736)
So it was just worn out, at almost 400k miles it had a lot of time on it.

I ask him the mileage he had on the vehicle when he discovered it was worn out. It is going on my list of things to check as I put more miles on my vehicle. Right not I am approaching 200,000 miles. After about 250,000 miles it looks like it is time to see what type of play is in the timer bushing.

I can also see a possible situation developing here. At around 300,000 the timing chain is stretched. The person changes the chain not thinking to check the Fuel Injection Pump Timer Bushing clearance. Some time down the road the Timer Bushing becomes worn and the Timer takes out Vacuum Pump and pieces of Vacuum Pump take out the new timing chain and possibly damaging other parts of the engine.

Diesel911 03-20-2008 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stevo (Post 1794336)
I had to remove the timing device on an engine I had just rebuilt because if forgot to replace the main oil gallery end plug :o, plug was in back of the T/D:eek: The "pin" was easy, getting the T/D out with the chain around it, another matter, I stuck a bunch of screw drivers and other "pointy' tools in there to hold the chain away, not fun:(

I took a look at the Manual to see what they used; they showed a whole bunch of screwdrives wedged under the timing chain just like you did.

Stevo 03-20-2008 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diesel911 (Post 1799390)
I took a look at the Manual to see what they used; they showed a whole bunch of screwdrives wedged under the timing chain just like you did.

Oh yah, in Haynes, they also show that "bushing" that wares out in back of the timing device.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Peach Parts or Pelican Parts Website