Dionysius |
09-28-2009 04:14 PM |
The Genesis of 'Nailing'
All of the following are from my personal experiences so please challenge me as you see fit. Some of this has not been written about or at least I have not come across it.
'Nailing' has many causes. The sound is produced from a secondary combustion event which is temporally and/or spatially separated (usually retarded in time) from the main explosion. Generally it can be caused by an Injector with an uneven spray pattern or with an imperfectly atomized trickle flow.
In a normal situation a coherent explosion with a smooth well defined flame profile occurs at the expected time. Nailing represents a perturbation to this process caused by one or more of the following:
- Assymetrical injector spray pattern
- Carbon build up in the pre-chamber and other explosion space
- Mechanical distortion or damage to the explosion space
- Damaged or distorted atomizer
- Air ingress into the hi pressure fuel lines (Many causes give rise to this including air ingress into the lo pressure side being referred into the hi pressure circuit sometimes but not always by the IP)
- Incorrect IP timing relative to crankshaft/cam timing
- Mal-adjusted valves
- Very low temperature in the explosion space caused by GP issues, low ambient conditions, etc.
- Low compression
I did this from my head so I may have missed some but you get the point.
As was pointed out it does acoustically sound somewhat like what is referred to as 'pinking' or 'pinging' or 'pre-ignition' where low octane gasoline is used in a hi-compression gasoline engine. It is a different phenomenon however in a Diesel engine since it is usually a retarded timing event that gives rise to 'Nailing'.
Is it bad for an engine?? Let us agree that it is not good but since these engines are extraordinarily robust it does no harm as long as it does not persist all through the operation. After warm up most nailing will disappear. 'Pre-ignition' in a gasoline engine however is very destructive. I have seen a piston with what looked like a bullet hole through its face from the effect.
Does it negatively affect MPG?? Of course the answer is yes. Energy is being used in an undesired manner that is not contributing to the desired power flow.
|