PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/)
-   Diesel Discussion (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/)
-   -   Problems troubleshooting low voltage at starter solenoid (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/280089-problems-troubleshooting-low-voltage-starter-solenoid.html)

funola 06-30-2010 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ah-kay (Post 2496849)
There is 1000 milliamps in 1Amp. The coil is an inductive load and the resistance will increase when you put DC voltage across the terminal. I have never measured it myself and it should be within the ballpark. The bottom line is that the coil wil pull at lower voltage to connect the starter directly to the battery, this is what make the engine to crank.

You are correct there is 1000 milliamps in 1A but you are way off on what the starter solenoiud draws. I just measured it on my 300DT and it drew 7 amps.

ah-kay 06-30-2010 07:44 PM

WOW. 7A. That is 84W for a solenoid. I do not expect that. That is still very small wattage compare to the total energy a battery can hold.

Additional info:

It was my mistake, I worked with switching relay before and normally the current is small. The solenoid needs to push the pinion gear in position, may be that is why it needs more energy. When I read the Wikipedia, it says

"A small electric current flowed through the starter relay coil, closing the contacts and sending a large current to the starter motor assembly." May be it is not that small after all.

Thanks for the info.

funola 06-30-2010 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oracle12345 (Post 2496989)
LOL get a better meter like a fluke

To accurately measure wire resistance, you need specialized test equipment. i.e a micro-ohmmeter. Fluke does not make one. They usually start at $400 and go up from there.

Here's one

http://www.ietlabs.com/IET/LOM-510.html

Note the range: 1 micro-ohm to 200 ohms

1 micro ohm is 1/1,000.000 of 1 ohm.

HinuWahie 06-30-2010 08:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LarryBible (Post 2496968)
I don't think you understand what I mean by a Voltage Drop test. The idea is not to check voltage at various points as referenced to ground. The idea is to check the voltage ACROSS individual components and connnections.

I totally do understand what you mean. I am curious about what the specific connection points you would use to do it, for my car. again, the solenoid for example, would use the solenoid lead, and the starter housing, and get the voltage while someone is cranking.

I dont know where they would be, if there are any, for the nss and the ignition switch.


Quote:

Originally Posted by LarryBible (Post 2496968)
Now, assuming that the solenoid is clicking in, put your leads across the solenoid itself while someone tries to start it. When that solenoid clicks in, there should be a virtual short across the terminals. If there are several volts dropped across the solenoid terminals (the big cable to the solenoid measured against the big connection that goes to the starter) then that means there is too much resistance across the solenoid terminals.

Maybe this is where the confusion is...its the lead that activates the solenoid that I have been refering to. the smaller (I guess 7A load carrying) terminal. In your terms, its the primary circuit I have issues with. I am getting good starting, with the seconday.

If you were going to do a voltage drop test for the nss and ignition switch, what connection point would you use?

micalk 06-30-2010 09:30 PM

You were kinda doing it when you figured out that you dropped 0.7 volts across the solenoid wire. You can measure all your voltages from a reference point like the negative battery post, or you can measure from one end of a wire to the other end. Whenever you have current flowing through a resistance you'll see a voltage drop which can be measured.

If you want to measure across the NSS and the start switch look in the schematic you should be able to do that at that junction box on the fender. You may have a few connection points thrown in the path, but you'll get a good idea of what's going on. With the solenoid connected, put one lead from your meter on the right hand pair of connections and put the other lead on the left hand connection where the solenoid connects. When you crank the engine, the voltage drop will tell you if you need to look at those switches.

LarryBible 07-01-2010 07:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oracle12345 (Post 2496989)
LOL get a better meter like a fluke

Regardless of the Ohmmeter used, it will not give you the same information as a voltage drop test. There is a miniscule amount of current passing through the element under test with an Ohmmeter. With a voltage drop test, you are passing plenty of current through the element, thus testing it's ability to pass lots of current.

LarryBible 07-01-2010 07:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HinuWahie (Post 2496785)
If I understand the Voltage drop test right, you:

1. hook up dmm in parralel with element being tested
2. take reading while cranking

I wanted to do that but, couldn't figure out how to isolate the elements in the starter circuit. The lead to the solenoid is easy enough, but where would you hook up to get the voltage drop accross nss, and ignition switch?


To get the voltage drop across the NSS, you connect your meter leads on the terminals of the NSS. You don't isolate anything, you simply measure voltage drop across any individual element in the circuit.

LarryBible 07-01-2010 07:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HinuWahie (Post 2497101)
I totally do understand what you mean. I am curious about what the specific connection points you would use to do it, for my car. again, the solenoid for example, would use the solenoid lead, and the starter housing, and get the voltage while someone is cranking.

I dont know where they would be, if there are any, for the nss and the ignition switch.




Maybe this is where the confusion is...its the lead that activates the solenoid that I have been refering to. the smaller (I guess 7A load carrying) terminal. In your terms, its the primary circuit I have issues with. I am getting good starting, with the seconday.

If you were going to do a voltage drop test for the nss and ignition switch, what connection point would you use?


Okay, the solenoid activation circuit can be tested in the same manner as the high current portion of the circuit. Just put your voltmeter leads across the item under test and see if it is dropping voltage. If it is open, then virtually all of the battery voltage will be dropped across that point.

It's DIFFICULT to describe things electronic without a schematic or black board, but let's say that you have B+ going to an ignition switch, then a neutral safety switch and then to the coil of a solenoid. If everything is correct, when the ignition switch is turned to start you will have virtually all (99+%) of B+ ACROSS the solenoid. That is with one lead on ground and the other on the solenoid power wire you will have B+, say 12 Volts.

NOW, let's say the resistance across the coil (yes I know it is an inductive load, but I'm trying to keep it simple) is 2 Ohms, then 12 Volts across 2 Ohms gives you 6 Amps although exactly how much current is in the circuit doesn't matter in what I'm trying to explain.

So NOW, let's say the NSS is open. Put your voltmeter leads across the NSS and turn on the ignition switch to start and you will see 12Volts across the switch. WHY? Because the resistance across the switch is infinite, while the resistance at the solenoid remains 2 Ohms. So you have BEAUCOUP resistance across the switch and relatively nothing across the solenoid. Forget the exact calculations, just remember that 99% or more of the circuit resistance is at the NSS, SO.. the Voltage is dropped across the NSS in your test.

Now take that same thinking to a situation where there is a dirty connection in the circuit causing say 2 Ohms resistance when carrying full current. That would mean that this dirty connection is dropping the same amount of voltage as the solenoid. So, the dirty connection would be dropping 6 Volts leaving only 6 Volts across the solenoid, which probably wouldn't pick it.

Does this help?

HinuWahie 07-01-2010 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LarryBible (Post 2497291)
It's DIFFICULT to describe things electronic without a schematic or black board, but

I appreciate the time and detail that you are providing. It is apparent you are trying to teach me over a very difficult medium (a forum) with the tools available. I really am thankful.

I just want to make it clear: I understand the theory (V=IR, In a series circuit the summation of Voltage drop at individual elements is equal to voltage applied to the entire circuit)
I understand the general methodology (apply dmm leads in parralel i.e. across element you want to determine Voltage drop on, looking for voltage draw at element while cranking, this is done sequentially on each element ).

I don't know the specifics of application for an '83 300sd, primary ignition circuit (e.g. nss, and ignition switch). I don't know where connect my leads to execute the test. Thats all I dont know about this test. Thats what would be helpful.

LarryBible 07-01-2010 01:13 PM

Okay, great. You're more than half way there. Understanding what you're testing and how to test it is the hard part.

NOW, what you're looking for is the location of the switches. I wish I could be more help with that. It seems like someone earlier in this thread or another thread recently described where to find the NSS. My 123 cars have been manual transmissions except one that my wife had and I never had to deal with this particular problem.

I would expect that if you get underneath and look at the transmission shift linkage you can find the switch. Maybe someone on here has an FSM for your car.

I am assuming that you have already checked for a voltage drop at the starter solenoid. That one is relatively easy to get at.

funola 07-01-2010 02:44 PM

Probing the test points can be a PITA if they are hard to access.

You said jumping the termimal block (small screw to big screw) nothing haopens. Did you try jumping small screw to battery + terminal? put a 20 A ammeter between the small screw and battery + terminal. The should pull in the startier solenoid and draw 7A..

ah-kay 07-01-2010 03:06 PM

One comment - high current DC ammeter is very expensive as ammeter is inherently intrusive to the circuit. It needs a very small value and precise resister to do the measurement. Most DIYers do not have one. Need plan B.

funola 07-01-2010 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ah-kay (Post 2497598)
One comment - high current DC ammeter is very expensive as ammeter is inherently intrusive to the circuit. It needs a very small value and precise resister to do the measurement. Most DIYers do not have one. Need plan B.

Most DVMs have a 20A scale that will do the job. I have a HF and a Craftsman at $15 and $25 respectively both have 20A scale. I wouldn't call that expensive..

LarryBible 07-01-2010 03:48 PM

So where did using an ammeter come into the discussion?

funola 07-01-2010 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LarryBible (Post 2497609)
So where did using an ammeter come into the discussion?

Since I measured my starter solenoid drawing 7 amps, I suggested Hinu do the same (if he has an ammeter). Real easy to do. Jump the terminal block with the ammeter. He should see around 7 amps and it should crank unless........


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:53 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Peach Parts or Pelican Parts Website