PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/)
-   Diesel Discussion (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/)
-   -   Need help on replacing rear shocks and springs without using sprng compressor. (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/diesel-discussion/390308-need-help-replacing-rear-shocks-springs-without-using-sprng-compressor.html)

Father Of Giants 12-09-2017 07:55 AM

Need help on replacing rear shocks and springs without using sprng compressor.
 
I'll start out buy saying I've never worked on suspension a day in my life, so I have not even the slightest clue on where I should start, No such thing as being to specific with me or giving too much "obvious info".

I quite honestly don't trust myself using a spring compressor and I also really just want to avoid buying one to get the job done. From what I've heard it is possible but there a quite a bit more steps involved.

Currently the car sags in the rear and dips forward with even the slightest application of the brakes which annoys me, it was like this when I got the car.

Where can shall I begin?

rocky raccoon 12-09-2017 08:11 AM

Maybe others know, but doesn't the SDL have air bag rear suspension?

Shocks can be replaced with no problems but Please Fatha, if you have springs to replace take your car to a suspension shop if you are uncomfortable with using a spring compressor.

Father Of Giants 12-09-2017 08:20 AM

Standard shocks and springs, bags or hydraulics.
I'm afraid of being charged an arm and leg just because I have the three point star on the hood. The only shops that can do it or Merc shops right?

leathermang 12-09-2017 09:53 AM

Being ' afraid' you are being charged an arm and a leg is better than LOSING a hand or fingers or eyes.... Springs are dangerous... use the proper equipment.... pay someone with the experience to Supervise you doing it perhaps....
I recommend that on Brake work where people are not familiar with the tricks to be sure they work properly.....

leathermang 12-09-2017 09:54 AM

I THINK you can RENT the spring compressor .. ???? Check on that....

Father Of Giants 12-09-2017 10:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by leathermang (Post 3771779)
I THINK you can RENT the spring compressor .. ???? Check on that....

The Baum tool?

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 10:39 AM

I'm planning a front end job in the near future. I'm thinking of wearing a Bell full coverage motorcycle helmet and gloves while using the spring compressor. I'm also thinking of some type of protection for my chest, metal plate, etc so that if the d*mn thing hits me in the chest it won't cause cardiac arrest.

I'm also thinking of figuring out a way to tie the spring to the chassis using steel cabling to prevent the spring from launching like a missile.

Might sound like overkill but these springs can reach out and grab you!

Diseasel300 12-09-2017 10:47 AM

You don't need a spring compressor to change the shocks. Replacing them will help out a LOT.

Unfortunately you do need a spring compressor for the springs, and the springs are an issue on these cars. The springs and rubber pads get tired and you get that "saggy ass" syndrome - especially with a full tank of gas and passengers in the rear seat. Mine does it too, but I'm not doing a thing to it until I have the time and money to rebuild the entire rear suspension. I installed the Bilstein "heavy duty" shocks on mine and it made a profound difference in the ride without being rough or jarring.

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 10:48 AM

Someone on this forum rents the Klann tool....can't remember who....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ytWwUdA-r8

rocky raccoon 12-09-2017 10:54 AM

Wrong!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Father Of Giants (Post 3771773)
Standard shocks and springs, bags or hydraulics.
I'm afraid of being charged an arm and leg just because I have the three point star on the hood. The only shops that can do it or Merc shops right?

Don't get caught in the Benz mystique. In the final analysis they are just cars. Things like suspension maintenance and brakes are about the same for all cars. No special equipment or tools needed. Any competent shop specializing in such things can easily do the jobs you describe as needed. Midas?

leathermang 12-09-2017 11:02 AM

There are many threads in the archives about changing out springs... the Two or Three brand compressors mentioned there may be necessary due to either the springs having many coils and close together or the tight fit in the area near them.... so I am not sure any Midas can properly do the job.

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 11:04 AM

I figure we should place a value on our time and expertise when dealing with cars. Everyone should value their own time at a minimum of $50 an hour. Professional mechanics use a guide to calculate the number of hours to perform a certain job. Their book might show new spring and shock replacement at 3.2 hours per wheel. They then take 3.2 hours and multiply it by their labor rate of say $100 and they come up with $320 per wheel.

So, we take our labor rate of $50 and multiply by 3.2 and come up with $160. So.....if we perform the work ourselves we saved ourselves $320 per wheel BUT we also have to place a value on our time which in this case is $160. The tough pill to swallow is nobody is paying us a dime to work on our cars. Plus, in the case of the OP, there is a risk to life and limb for this particular repair.

Now, if we have a skill that pays us $100 per hour and we don't get our hands dirty or risk our lives, it is better to work at that and swap dollars with the repair shop.

Another idea is bartering for work. Say you are a plumber; you approach ten auto repair shops and let them know you will offer them ten hours of free plumbing at either their business location or their home in exchange for repairing the shocks and springs on your mercedes. When you call, ask to speak with the owner of the business. I've learned over the years that most will say no, but if you keep dialing and smiling you will get a YES.

If you use this idea, be sure and check out the repair shops on yelp.com and this forum's reviews before you call and make them an offer.

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 11:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by leathermang (Post 3771789)
There are many threads in the archives about changing out springs... the Two or Three brand compressors mentioned there may be necessary due to either the springs having many coils and close together or the tight fit in the area near them.... so I am not sure any Midas can properly do the job.

I wouldn't trust Midas or Meineke to work on the brakes, shocks, struts or springs for any european car. I did have a Meineke do exhaust work on a 1984 300DT once. The indy that had previously replaced the transmission had seen the exhaust problem while doing the transmission work but failed to tell me about it.

I was 800 miles from home when the exhaust started banging and causing serious problems. I was referred to a Meineke shop who was kind of enough to stay past normal business hours to repair the exhaust and did a GREAT job. That said, I don't think I would want a Meineke or Midas to do any suspension or brake work on a european car.

Mxfrank 12-09-2017 11:19 AM

Why? Anything prior to the 211 has the most ordinary of brake systems. And as long as it doesn’t have SLS, the suspension couldn’t be simpler.

larryloveslala 12-09-2017 11:24 AM

I just had shocks put on by a local budget brakes. I had the shocks already and they only charged me 40 a corner. It was worth it to me because I don't have a car lift and believe me it's much easier with a lift. Jack stands and a floor jack just don't cut it. Took them an hour and a half at it would have taken me all day!

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 11:28 AM

Any work involving the removal of springs on these beasts should be approached with a caution. We all have varying degrees of mechanical skills. In addition, unless we work on cars eight to ten hours a day, we don't have near the everyday experience of dealing with them that a professional mechanic has.

Plus, most of us don't have a mechanic buddy who is willing to come to our location and oversee our work. That is why we rely on this forum so heavily.

There are some jobs that are best turned over to a professional; anything involving spring removal may be one of them. It isn't worth losing an eye or getting maimed or killed over.

ykobayashi 12-09-2017 11:28 AM

The compressors are really cheap now. I bought a Klann knockoff from Taiwan a decade ago that works great. It cost me $150. The new ones from China Mainland cost $100 the last time I saw them. Those might be scary but they look like they’ll work.

A lot better than no compressor. Yikes:eek:

As for safety I wear gloves and glasses. The Bell helmet may be a good call. Cannot be too safe when you’re dealing with a cannon.

I work with the axis of the spring parallel to me. That is, if the spring breaks the compressor thread it’ll shoot most of it’s energy in a safe direction. I also work with it on the lawn, so if it does go boing it doesn’t have anything to recoil off of and surprise me. Finally when it is compressed, if I’m going to be doing some suspension work like ball joints or anything that will delay me, I decompress the spring ...I don’t leave it like a cocked ballista in my driveway. Not the best precautions but I’ve stayed out of trouble.

Good luck. You are scary. Rent the tool from somebody here.

Don’t go to arseholes like Midas or Menike. You’ll be sold too many additional services and all of them suck.

Edit- for goodness sakes. I just checked eBay and you can get a set of compressors for $55 shipped. Buy a set and be done with it.

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 11:31 AM

Last visit to a Meineke they had a 20 something manning the front desk. He was texting on his smart phone and acted like it was a total bother dealing with customers.

ROLLGUY 12-09-2017 11:34 AM

NO COMPRESSOR NEEDED FOR REAR SPRINGS
 
If you are changing the springs on the rear, no compressor is needed! All you need to do is jack up the rear of the car, and place jack stands just forward of the rear of the front subframe mounting bolts (they need to be loosened). Remove the wheels, and shocks. Loosen the large bolts that hold the front of the subframe to the car. Only about four revolutions should do. Put your floor jack under the differential, and remove the four bolts holding the rear diff mount to the car. Lower the jack all the way, and the springs SHOULD FALL OUT. If they don't, loosen the front bolts a little more. Now, if you are doing the FRONT springs, you will definitely need a quality spring compressor.

ykobayashi 12-09-2017 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ROLLGUY (Post 3771806)
If you are changing the springs on the rear, no compressor is needed! r.

Thank you you’re right. I am Starting to lose memory. I’m sitting in my shop staring at my rear rubber shims still wrapped in the plastic. I don’t think I ever removed the rears on my cars. I planned on it and read the diy (here?) on how to drop the spring by lowering the arm with a floor jack. Of course a compressor will work but it is a luxury.

I put thin shims up front and called it a day - and Yes I did use the compressor. Fixed saggy butt. As stated here those coils on mb are very closely spaced. The autozone compressor won’t work. So there is Benz mystique at work.

Btw I used the cheap Meyle shims and they make noise after five years. Next time I’ll get OE.

Father Of Giants 12-09-2017 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ROLLGUY (Post 3771806)
If you are changing the springs on the rear, no compressor is needed! All you need to do is jack up the rear of the car, and place jack stands just forward of the rear of the front subframe mounting bolts (they need to be loosened). Remove the wheels, and shocks. Loosen the large bolts that hold the front of the subframe to the car. Only about four revolutions should do. Put your floor jack under the differential, and remove the four bolts holding the rear diff mount to the car. Lower the jack all the way, and the springs SHOULD FALL OUT. If they don't, loosen the front bolts a little more. Now, if you are doing the FRONT springs, you will definitely need a quality spring compressor.

Yeah, this was the answer I was looking for. Where exactly are the sub frame bolts?

HuskyMan 12-09-2017 02:41 PM

If it were my car I'd call a minimum of four euro indy repair companies and ask for a quote for labor. Ask them if you can bring your own parts....some allow it, some don't. Ask them how much time it will take them to perform the work. Now take the amount of time they quote and double it.

That figure will be the approximate time it takes someone who is not experienced to perform the same job. Take that figure and multiply it times $50/hour. Say eight hours times $50 would be $400 out of hip national bank plus busted and skinned up knuckles, wrenches breaking loose coming back and hitting you in the face, etc etc.

Another idea; I've noticed that indy repair shops located outside the big city, i.e. jerkwater charge substantially LESS to do the same repairs the big city guys charge big bucks for. Yes, you need to do some yelp.com checking and/or acquire the yellow pages for the jerkwater areas but you may find a quality, competent indy who will do work for you for substantially less money than the big city indies.

Speaking of which, one of my associates decided he needed two new cars. He shopped the big city dealers who weren't willing to cut a deal. He ultimately went to a small jerkwater car dealer who sold him the exact same cars the way he wanted them optioned for $12,000 LESS than the big city dealers. He has a vacation home which requires him to travel through jerkwater so he simply stops in and gets his oil changed, general maintenance etc. $12,000.00 is $12,0000.00 anyway you look at it.

ROLLGUY 12-09-2017 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Father Of Giants (Post 3771842)
Yeah, this was the answer I was looking for. Where exactly are the sub frame bolts?

They are near the rear jack points. There is a plate that has two smaller bolts (17mm tool?) that need to be loose as well, or the plate will bend. Changing the rear springs on these cars is actually quite easy, and should take an hour or less.

Father Of Giants 12-10-2017 10:44 AM

Ordered the parts, shocks, springs, and spring pads. Well. see what happens.

Diseasel300 12-10-2017 01:26 PM

Keep us updated on the rear, if it's an easy job, that's the first thing happening to mine this coming year. Sick of the ass hunkering down all the time!

DeliveryValve 12-11-2017 12:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Father Of Giants (Post 3771842)
Yeah, this was the answer I was looking for. Where exactly are the sub frame bolts?

I really haven't had to touch the front sub frame bolts to drop any springs.

You just really have to remove the shocks, drop the exhaust, unbolt the single round diff mount and then lower the subframe to the lowest point until the spring can fall out. Once the spring is fully extended and it's still there, you might need to pry it out a little bit. Of course if you still can't get it out, then you can resort to loosening the front sub frame mounts.


.

spark3542 12-12-2017 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeliveryValve (Post 3772299)
I really haven't had to touch the front sub frame bolts to drop any springs.


.

I agree. On my 83, I never loosened the subframe bolts, just the 4 bolts around the differential, and drop it gently watching that the driveshaft/flex discs don't bind too much. Springs will fall out.

vstech 12-13-2017 08:25 AM

Unless you live in Arizona, hope you don’t need to loosen the subframe bolts...

Bring a 3/4” breaker bar or a 1/2” one and a Long pipe for leverage...

TIGHT...

Usually, all cars prior to 124 design don’t need the compressor for REAR spring removal...

You can do it with a 124 design, but if you are changing links, it’s much easier with the short shaft KLANN compressor...

Father Of Giants 12-19-2017 02:28 PM

I can't thank you guys enough!

If it does have to come down to loosing the subframe bolts, is it advised I buy new subframe mounts ahead of time just in case the old ones are destroyed?

ROLLGUY 12-19-2017 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Father Of Giants (Post 3774375)
I can't thank you guys enough!

If it does have to come down to loosing the subframe bolts, is it advised I buy new subframe mounts ahead of time just in case the old ones are destroyed?

It is a major deal to replace the mounts/bushings. It may be possible to replace them without totally removing the subframe from the car, but I don't see how. They don't come out easy, and you will need some sort of press to install them. Also, the brake lines will have to come off either way, as you won't get enough droop of the subframe without stretching the brake lines.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:51 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Peach Parts or Pelican Parts Website