I have two AMG monoblocks in 17 x 7.5" for the front and two 17 x 8.5" for the rear. I was told that 235/45-17 tires would fit on all four. Is there a downside to doing this ? Car is a 1999 W210.
Many thanks,
Ken

I know Tirerack recommends using 255/40/17. Its probably because 265/40/17s (even though a perfect match) might rub and 265s might not fit on 8.5" wide rims.

235/45/17s will fit on an 8.5" rim, but I don't see the purpose of it. You still wouldn't be able to rotate your tires cause the wider wheels would not fit properly in the front. I would use 255/40/17s in the back, and 235/45/17s in the front.

Just my suggestion for a w210. A nice tire to try is the Yokohama AVS dB available in both sizes too.

Good luck.

Charlie.

__________________
Chirag (Charlie) Patel
--------------------------------------------
- 03 Mercedes S600 Sport TTV12
- 97 Acura NSX-T
- 99 BMW E36 M3 w/500+ HP
- 04 Lexus RX330
- 04 Dodge Dakota Quad 4x4 V8

4 Sale:
- 99 BMW M3 E36 Coup with Dinan SC, Upgraded to an RMS Stage 3 with Aftercooler, 12psi, and 500+hp @ flywheel.