Time to upgrade my wife's 95 C220, which is now in the shop for the head gasket/wiring harness/etc. I'm looking at a 99 or 00 E320 for her.

The question involves the car that I "inherit" for my use, usually for no more than 6000 miles per year. Short work commutes and occasional long trips.

The 95 C220 has 135K miles, and doesn't have have a single dent. scratch, or tear. After the current work, the mechanicals will be excellent. I really enjoy driving this car.

My existing car, an 85 300 SD, has 185K miles but is still in good mechanical shape. In terms of cosmetics, it needs the leather seats repaired, grill replaced, and a new dash pad - probably $2K to make it presentable. It has minor issues such as temperature regulation and cruise control.

I expect to drive one of these two MBs for the next four or five years. On average, which would be expected to have fewer problems and expenses - the newer gas 95 C220 or the older diesel 85 300SD?

Not looking for crystal ball answers - just best guesses based upon experience.

Thanks,

BBC