PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/index.php)
-   Off-Topic Discussion (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Cosby's comments (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/showthread.php?t=164854)

davestlouis 09-18-2006 07:30 PM

People voluntarily segregate themselves all day long...there are very few churches that are not segregated, for instance. And it's not all directed toward black people. Xenophobia is a normal human thing.

BENZ-LGB 09-18-2006 07:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mistress (Post 1280274)
Oye Mojito- Soy es Heinz 57, es una mongrel, I am many thins....alittle of this alittle of that.

Mongrels are the best...the mix makes them, how shall I put this...más caliente...:D

Or at least that is what California's Gobernator thinks.

Hatterasguy 09-18-2006 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dculkin (Post 1280276)
For what it's worth, I would imagine that there are grandchildren of slaves still among us. Say a slave born in 1860 had a child at age 35 and then that child had the slave's grandchild at age 35. The grandchild would be 76 today. Doesn't seem farfetched to me.

My point is not to do the math, but to point out that we had things like slavery and government-sponsored racial discrimination for a long, long time and that the time since they were abolished is relatively short. None of this is intended to provide excuses for anyone, but I think it's important to keep in mind. Old ways die hard and I don't think that it is accurate to say that slavery does not affect anybody currently alive. For example, there are probably plenty of white Americans whose great-grandparents owned slaves. You don't think that experience affected the current generation? I would have to disagree. Speaking for myself, I would have to say that my great-grandparents' lives continue to affect me in ways that I could not articulate.

BTW, I have not paid great attention to everything Bill Cosby has said on this subject, but what I have heard from him sounds like it's right on target.

To change the subject slightly, there are probably many people alive today whose great-grandparents were alive during Thomas Jefferson's life. We have a young country.


And? My great grandmother is 96 or 97 years old, my great grandfather died about 7 years ago. I respect them and care for them but they have little if any affect on my life. My grandparents on the other hand, thats a totaly different story.

Our country is young, and I am pretty sure if I looked into it my family held slaves, probably a fair number. But the past is the past, I was born in 1985, what happened in the mid 19th century doesn't have any bearing on my life beyond a history test.

I still stick by what I said before, it ended in 1865 there is no one alive who was directly affected by slavery. If you were 100 years old, maybe your grand parents could have been slaves, I could see that.

Botnst 09-18-2006 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BENZ-LGB (Post 1280287)
....The Great Society has been a great disappointment in so many ways.

I blame government for trying to shove things down peoples' throats. I can tell you that, form a personal POV, as an educated Hispanic male, Affirmative Action has been more of a burden than a benefit.

I got into a good college based on my good high school record. I got into a good law school based on my good college record. Still, I have to spend time and effort proving to others that I am "good" and not just a product of Affirmative Action!

Damn.

As generalization I agree with you. And since I've worked in the gov for the past couple of decades my perspective is likely to be heavily skewed because prior to GS I worked in the oil industry. In most instances the oil industry is a highly competitive meritocracy. for example, I went from day laborer to running a survey crew in Argentina in 3 years. I worked my butt of from before daybreak to after dark 6 or 7 days a week. My employers rewarded me with more work and significant pay increases. At that time there were just a few African-Americans working in surveying and they were all laborers, like me. I was lucky for 2 reasons: First, that my superiors were looking for talent as their company expanded and second because I was white. There is no doubt in my mind that any man who worked hard could have gotten ahead at that time (it isn't always the case). My bosses made no secret of having a racial preference and I benefitted by it.

Had A.A. NOT been held as a threat over employers heads I have absolutely no doubt that most white supervisors would have preferentially hired and advanced whites. That was the way the world was back then and it sucked for minorities.

My final example is this. I had three Hispanic guys working for me, none of whom spoke English. They were smart and hard-working but poorly educated. But they were eager as heck to do anything I asked of them so I started teaching them trigonometry and drawing. They were ignorant and uneducated, not stupid. It was still slow going for them because of the language barrier and because of their lack of formal education passed I'd guess 5th grade math. But they were determined and I couldn't ask for better hands so we worked on it. I got transferred to Michigan from Wyoming. I asked the guys if they wanted to go with me or stay in Wyoming and I was gratified that they wanted to go with me. My company paid for the move and they drove some company vehicles.

We were in Michigan for several weeks and some union guy wanted us to organize. I wasn't interested, like most oilfield guys. Apparently nobody else did either. A short time later, maybe a week or so, we got visited by the INS and 2 of my guys were not citizens and they got deported. Ask me what I think of unions.

Bot

mikemover 09-18-2006 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Botnst (Post 1280451)
Ask me what I think of unions.

Bot


You probably like them about as much as I do. ;)

Mike

Botnst 09-18-2006 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikemover (Post 1280477)
You probably like them about as much as I do. ;)

Mike

My 'appreciation' comes from being damned certain they were the ones who dropped a dime on my guys AFTER we declined the union representation. I think it was just meanness. They could hurt people and pay no consequences so they did. I can imagine them laughing about it to this day. Bastards.

B

davestlouis 09-18-2006 08:41 PM

On the subject of adults who want to be treated like spoiled children and refuse to accept responsibility for themselves, union members are at the top of the list. They are effectively welfare recipients, being paid $25/hr for menial work and in the case of UAW workers, getting 95% of base pay even when the plant is closed.

davestlouis 09-18-2006 08:43 PM

I was a member of management at a company whose delivery drivers were teamsters. If you asked a driver to do something he didn't feel like doing, his response was "talk to my steward" which was effectively "let my daddy deal with it because I don't feel like it". Don't get me started!

davestlouis 09-18-2006 08:49 PM

I have an x-brother in law who worked at the DaimlerChrysler plant in Fenton MO...UAW worker. He missed more than 1/2 of his scheduled days the last year he was there, due to a meth problem, but the union protected him and kept his job for him...until he got busted selling meth in the plant, then he was finally gone. At a normal job he would have been out on his ear a long time ago...and this was a guy with a GED, not exactly a genius, making $60,000 a year. Now that he blew that gig and is out of prison, he works odd jobs and by my guesstimate, is living in poverty. One could argue that, given his education, skill set and job history, that's where he belonged all along.

Honus 09-18-2006 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hatterasguy (Post 1280429)
...I still stick by what I said before, it ended in 1865 there is no one alive who was directly affected by slavery...

Whatever "directly" means. Your earlier comment was broader:
Quote:

...there is no one currantly alive that has been affected by it...
Slavery actually ended in 1863, not 1865, but there is no way that the effects of slavery ended then. IMHO, slavery's aftermath is still with us. It's not an excuse for the dysfunction described by Bill Cosby. Likewise, the Emancipation Proclamation is not an excuse for those who wield the power in this country to assume that we have a level playing field. That's all I'm saying. I'm not trying to make any larger point than that.

Hatterasguy 09-18-2006 10:40 PM

Ok, understood. There were still slaves up until the south surrendered. Only Slaves in waring states were freed, slaves in Union border states remained.

t walgamuth 09-18-2006 10:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikemover (Post 1280394)
You're joking, right?... You seriously think this was actual, enforced "segregation" that you saw in 1996????...

:rolleyes:

I submit that it was mere coincidence, and you saw in it what you wanted to see.

Mike

first the chain gang. how much more enforced could it be? there were guys with shotguns watching them.

second. the restaruant. i saw what i saw. ALL whites on one side of the aisle next to the windows. ALL blacks aginst the blank wall, closer to the noise of the kitchen. i suppose you can see coincedence there. i dont. my freind who was traveling with me saw it the same way i did.

YOU can see whatever you want to, too.

tom w

t walgamuth 09-18-2006 11:04 PM

unions?
 
my favorite union bumper sticker is:

"organized labor...the folks who brought you the weekend".

unions have done a lot of good in this country. the country has a very short memory. before unions, blue collar folks worked six or seven days a week twelve to fourteen hours a day, died young and never had anything.

unions brought blue collar folks into the middle class. made them consumers. got them health insurance and pensions. they all bought houses two cars a boat a harley etc. this drove our economy and helped place our country where it is. the economic leader of the world.

now many of my friends, i swear, believe that blue collar folks should not have anything and should not be able to be middle class and would like nothing better than to push the blue collar folks back down. at present these folks seem to be winning.

now i have worked on jobs that were union. teamsters even. a lot of what is complained about here i have seen first hand. there is no doubt that there have been abuses. but before the unions got power, the abuses by the big industrial employers were just huge.

here in lafayette we have several large factorys that are non union. cat is the most prominent example. the guys that work there ( alot of them) like to say "who needs a union, they treat me just fine. i make $35/ hr. etc etc."

if there was not a union in the peoria cat plant there is NO WAY IN H*LL that they would have it as good as they have it here....NO WAY.

so i am not a hard core union organizer but i appreciate what they have done for working folks. if they continue to lose stature and the laws are changed, it will not be good for anybody. working conditions and wages and our economic prosperity will all decline drastically.

so dont be too hard on them,... they really did bring you the weekend.

tom w

EricSilver 09-18-2006 11:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikemover (Post 1280324)
Rubbish.
His "rhetoric", as you call it, serves a GREAT purpose..

Yes, it annoys and alienates the people he criticizes -- who will absolutely not take his advice -- and therefore does nothing to solve the problem.

The great purpose it really serves, in the minds of many white people, is to absolve them of any sense of responsibility or guilt for the impact of their historical and current day attitudes and behaviors on the lives of Black people.

EricSilver 09-19-2006 12:27 AM

How did I miss this one:

Quote:

Originally Posted by davestlouis (Post 1279240)
I find it shameful that some people ... will spend all day Sunday at church, praying for things to improve, when they should be out there, trying to improve things.

You mean, people like Cosby? :idea2:

Should he be out there trying to improve things? And if so, how -- by insulting and yelling at people, or by rolling up his sleeves and actually doing something meaningful?

Quote:

Originally Posted by davestlouis (Post 1279240)
Other minority groups try to assimilate, while some blacks try to distance themselves with their speech and dress.

For generations, Blacks wanted one thing above all: To be ordinary Americans. But they were denied. Now many say "F**k it." I may not agree, but I definitely understand.

Quote:

Originally Posted by davestlouis (Post 1279240)
Guess what, the majority doesn't like those who don't go along with the group....

Wait -- I thought it was the Black people who had the herd mentality and followed leaders in a groupthink manner?

Quote:

Originally Posted by davestlouis (Post 1279240)
and these people with funny names, baggy britches, and garbled speech are going nowhere.

Some of them, with funny names like "Kanye" (West), "Snoop," "Nas," "2-Pac," etc. have gone straight to the bank, cashing in on Hip Hop culture, selling music with garbled lyrics to millions of non-black listeners. By the way, what do you think of Eminem?

Quote:

Originally Posted by davestlouis (Post 1279240)
As long as they are aware of the consequences of that choice to stand out, so be it, but they can't expect society to accept them.

In their minds, society will not accept them one way or another. Is their attitude, therefore, really surprising?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Peach Parts or Pelican Parts Website