PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/index.php)
-   Tech Help (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Please help- $3500 because no compression (http://www.peachparts.com/shopforum/showthread.php?t=123293)

angeliamce 05-13-2005 07:31 PM

Please help- $3500 because no compression
 
Please help- couple of weeks washed car motor and immediately had major motor problems. Dealership called they are not sure what is wrong with the car, they are sure that washing the motor could not cause compression problems in the cylinder. Basically, they want to pull the heads ($600) Monday (5/16/05) to see what is going on. I asked if there could be anything else wrong since pulling the heads is $600. They explained they had pulled the plugs and there was no compression in cylindar 1 therefore there must be a problem w/ the valves or pistons? I am so scared- they said to plan for around $3500 maybe more. I have a 1995 C220- I purchased it used and still owe money and this is my only vehicle. Could it be anything besides something that requires pulling the heads? I have been dealing w/ these guys for a couple of years and they seem honest, but 3500 seems like a lot of money. Also could compression be affected by the timing? thanks for any advice

r_p_ryan 05-13-2005 08:40 PM

you don't 'pull the heads' as a diagnostic step.

Roncallo 05-13-2005 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by angeliamce
Please help- couple of weeks washed car motor and immediately had major motor problems. Dealership called they are not sure what is wrong with the car, they are sure that washing the motor could not cause compression problems in the cylinder. Basically, they want to pull the heads ($600) Monday (5/16/05) to see what is going on. I asked if there could be anything else wrong since pulling the heads is $600. They explained they had pulled the plugs and there was no compression in cylindar 1 therefore there must be a problem w/ the valves or pistons? I am so scared- they said to plan for around $3500 maybe more. I have a 1995 C220- I purchased it used and still owe money and this is my only vehicle. Could it be anything besides something that requires pulling the heads? I have been dealing w/ these guys for a couple of years and they seem honest, but 3500 seems like a lot of money. Also could compression be affected by the timing? thanks for any advice

I find it hard to belive that this is a MB dealership. A leakdown test needs to be performed before pulling heads. That will tell if you have bad valves rings etc. If they are not willing to do this first get the car out of there.

Yes VALVE timing can cause low compession. Ignition timing will have no effect on compression.

John Roncallo

deanyel 05-13-2005 10:04 PM

You need to get a second opinion from the best independent shop you can find. This is all very fishy. It doesn't cost much to buy a compression tester - maybe $20 at Harbor Freight, and it isn't hard to do. It's the one way to actually know whether you have a compression problem. I'll bet you don't. Also, you gotta tell us how many miles on the car - 50k or 250k makes a difference.

newbieNabors 05-14-2005 04:48 PM

Wow! what a coincidence.
I too have the same problem.

Corbin Dallas 05-14-2005 07:37 PM

Was the car running when you washed the engine?

angeliamce 05-15-2005 04:50 PM

The car is 1995 c220 w/ 135,000 miles- the car was turned off when the motor was washed. Also, the technician said that the problem must be w/ my valves or piston, because a compression test was done by pulling out the spark plugs and each cylinder was checked w/ cylinder 1 having no compression. I really appreciate the advice- but there are no second opinions around and this is my only car. I don't want to make the mechanic angry, but I have a big problem w/ them doing something that cost $600 when they are not sure what is wrong. The way they explained it to me is that they have not dealt w/ a problem like this before and must pull the head off to rule out the valve or bent piston. Also, they are sure that the water was just a chance thing and has no association.

brewtoo 05-15-2005 06:15 PM

Washing the engine would not cause a compression loss.

With bad rings there would be SOME compression. Also the rings would not go bad suddenly.

The only thing that could cause NO compression would be a valve stuck open.

That's not too common.

Are you saying the engine was running fine when it was shut down for washing but then had problems immediately upon the next start?

Rob Pruijt 05-15-2005 06:45 PM

There can be several reasons for losing compression in a cylinder.
Either there is no air coming in, of there is a (big) leak.
The first thing to do is to test with compressed air if and where it leaks, this is a very simple test. If the air goes to the bottom (carter) you have a hole in the piston (bad), If it goes to the exhaust (with the valves closed) the exhaust valve is burnt (less bad), if it comes out at the side or front the gasket is blown (even less bad).
Of course there are other possibilities, but they make a lot of noise.
For looking inside a cylinder you don’t have to pull the head, with a scope it is very easy to loo through a sparkplug hole.

The only reason this dealer can have to pull the head is to make sure you must stay with them and you are forced to pay whatever they charge you. Without a head you can’t drive and since you owe them $600 they can work the bill up from there.

So take your car out and find a independent shop. In general the price/quality can be measured by the amount of grease on the owners hands. Information about independent shops can be obtained by family, neighbours, people at gas stations, taxi’s, or anyone on the street driving an old car. If you make some work of it you can get a good picture of local car shops in a reasonable short time. A good independent shop gets it customers through other customers and not because of a Mercedes sign.

angeliamce 05-15-2005 08:49 PM

Are you saying the engine was running fine when it was shut down for washing but then had problems immediately upon the next start?

Immediately. Yes, the car was like a brand new car w/ no problems. Engine was turned off, motor washed, inside vaccumed, and then car would not start. After several attempts car finally started but gas had to be given continuously or car would die. Car's motor seemed to shake and car jumped but then would drive normally, but then start jumping and would die at stops.

fj bertrand 05-15-2005 08:57 PM

While your car is being worked on RENT A CAR. Don't let them force you over a barrel to make a decision. Rent a car and take it somewhere else...

jim16671836 05-15-2005 09:31 PM

Wet Ignition
 
It really sounds like you have got the wiring wet...at the coil or someplace...to me that is why it would not start and why when it did, it ran ratty....I don't know much about your engine..maybe you need to take your car elsewhere...compression check is eady to do...pull all the sparkplugs and coil wire and have a friend or your wife turn the engine over quickly at least 5 times...during this process hold any thing(a screwdrive with a rubber end) that will seal the number 1 hole and if you have compression it will force its way past what you are holding it against the hole...you can check a few of them and you will get a good idea if number 1 has compression...but your problem sounds electrical....you can call me if you do not understand my instructions...1-812-897-0667 Jim Harris If I am out leave your number and I will call you back...Jim

kim Langley 05-16-2005 07:57 AM

I'm with Jim..

Usually problems associated with washing the engine compartment is that water gets into electrical connections and shorts htings out...

Go to a Autozone of car-parts shop and buy a comression tester.. very simple to use one

angeliamce 05-16-2005 08:54 AM

It is 7:45 a.m. in Arkansas and I just got off the phone w/ the mercedes service department. I explained that I would like a scope test before pulling the heads. The technician explained that at this point they know that it is a valve problem- nothing else cause compression problems. Basically, they are going to do $600 worth of work and now I feel he is angry. I hope they are honest. Have a good day! Angie

jim16671836 05-16-2005 09:07 AM

Just Be Firm
 
Tell him you decided you do not want it fixed....Just be FIRM.....Jim


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2024 Pelican Parts, LLC - Posts may be archived for display on the Peach Parts or Pelican Parts Website