Woohoo! Problem solved!
Thanks for the input everybody!
This morning I got the part at the counter, then went to the cashier who asked for about $128 (with tax).
I went back to the parts counter to tell the man it was $83 on the phone yesterday... after typing at his computer for a minute he said: "ok, you can go back to the counter" Total was $89.
I then went back to the parts counter and asked why there was a price difference since I will prob be buying parts in the future, he said: "They gave you a discount and didn't tell me", hmmm... all I did was call up yesterday, they had no idea who they were talking to.
