Switching from stock to a plus 1 or plus 2 fittment will always be a ride vs handling issue. Just keep the overall rolling radius the same. It all depends on your personal priorities. Lower profile rubber and stickier tires will handle better. They might ride more harshly, generate more noise, or wear quicker than stock as well. Driving style and specific tire choice has more impact on longevity than any particular size difference. Check this site out to browse some choices. http://www.tirerack.com Best of luck, Lee