Arthur - you won't believe it. Pulled the splash pan to get to the starter (from underneath) - whacked it with the hammer a few times - VROOOOOM. Started her up 10 times in a row.

Whew - that's great news. I can't believe my old mustang restoration/mechanical skills didn't kick in, and I didn't think of whacking it earlier. But, not used to having a solenoid on top of the starter motor - lol.

OK - so what does this mean? Starter is on it's way out? Solenoid? Or just a flukey think that may not happen again? Boy - do I appreciate it, my friend.