Thanks to everyone for their suggestions and input. I have some good values to go by. I'll make a decision on where to take it in the next few days. The shop in a town that a trusted place recommended is also a "service first" shop with my insurance co., which is State Farm. That means the shop is authorized to do the appraisal for State Farm instead of SF having to send out a separate appraiser.

Does anyone see any issues with a shop like that?

They come recommended from a high end used car store that I have bought from in the past. His brother also has a shop that caters to Brumos Mercedes and Porsche.

Anyone have any body shop suggestions in the Jacksonville, FL area?