I can´t remember what the problem was, but I have had exactly the same experience (two spinning screws) and got it to work without anything but getting the pieces (cover and screws) in the right place...

__________________
-94 E 36 AMG Coupé, Brilliant Silver
-98 G 500, Obsidian Black
-05 Mini Cooper, Solid Black
-97 993 Carrera S, Ocean Blue