Quote:
Originally Posted by POS
The argument against the death tax is small business owners. We are already taxed on the business at every level - own a business sometime and you'll quickly learn that the government thinks our income streams are an excellent source of more revenue (income taxes, franchise taxes, property taxes) - and now after a lifetime of working to build a company, the kids get taxed yet again when I die when they inherit the business and the assets I've spent a lifetime building. It only affects those who hold "great wealth"? Are you kidding me? We bust our ass, take high risk, and invest all our lifetime savings to build something for our families, and when we die, the government takes half of it from my family. They think the money was just "found money" to my kids anyways, but I earned that money by living with high amounts of stress, dodging regular bullets, and a lot of time away from home to make sure my kids get a better-than-average head start on life.
Take the easy way, be an employee. No high risk, no high gain, no death tax. For hundreds of thousands of us, we strike out on our own, use our abilities to build something that supports our employees and their families too, reinvest all our savings to keep the business going, and then get whacked by the government for half our stuff on our deathbeds. The death tax is immoral.
|
I just don't see it that way. When you die, the money you leave to your children is unearned income to them. "because you died" is not a good enough reason for your children to dodge the income tax. As I stated earlier, we need to treat all income the same - while this is after-tax money to you, the dead guy, to the living, it is income. Capital gains, earned income, inheritance income above a certain point (which, contrary to your assertion is fabulous wealth to most people at the current 3.5 million of exempted estate) all should be taxed at around 12 percent IMO. I just don't see how, especially given the fact you would be dead at the time, this would be much skin off your behind.
I also think one way we might also compromise is for as all to admit that the entire income tax system in this country is a failure and is utterly unable to equitably divide the burden, that we scrapped the damned thing and institute a VAT tax, which at least assures that all will pay something.