Confirmed the drivers side shock is leaking profusely. Probably the passengers side has been leaking for awhile and the fluid level dropped low enough to starve the other or an air bubble burst the seal. I noticed the fluid level had dropped a bit but it was still within specs. Must have been the terrible roads in my area that finished off both of them.

So the best price I found for OEM shocks was autopartswarehouse for $390 a piece. Seems there's an option to just eliminate the hydraulic system entirely and go with standard shocks, that may be the best option.

OK even shaved 100 more and couldn't pass it up: