Gerry, the part number & photo you show above (201 899 00 08) is the plastic plug for the jack hole in the rocker panel of pre-1990 models, for the emergency crank-style jack in the trunk. It's not the jack pad under the car designed for lifting with a floor jack or vehicle hoist.
The under-bod jack lifting point pad is in the EPC as "Take-up device lock at floor, hard-rubber buffer used for jack". Group 58, subgroup 015, callout number varies with chassis.
The pre-1990 jack pad is part number 124-997-04-86, photos below. This pad will not fit 90-up cars because the rocker panel will interfere:
The 1990-95 jack pad is part number 001-997-95-86. The photo below is
NOT what it looks like on the car. The pads on my 1994/95 cars are round & stubby, and do not have that weird cylindrical standoff sticking up out of it. I suspect that plastic center piece is an installation or removal aid, meant to be pressed up into the pad when on the car? It definitely is not supposed to be sticking down 3 inches below the car. Regardless, after looking at ps2cho's photo again, it appears that the plastic itself kerploded on the crappy Meyle part. Just buy OE, they are less than $10 list price each.