You cannot have your pie and eat it too. They have to be sure they aquire what intelligence they can. Drugs would be used rather than torture I suspect.

If they did not do so and something else happened this serious or worse as a proven result.. There would be hell to pay. For all practical purposes they were soldiers of a movement to attack America with a declared agenda. Not common criminals.

He cannot be allowed to hide behind legal systems and rights.This is probably nothing new and has been a standing arrangement for some time makes sense.

Technically if his citizenship is revoked he has no rights. What right did he have to participate in killing and damaging almost two hundred people? With implications it is part of a general movement in nature. Unfortunatly more information may have been gathered from his older brother but that option is gone.

If legal council is given before there is assurance the information is complete. It could set unhealthy precidents for the future. For all practical purposes they still were soldiers for a radical movement to attack America.No matter how inept they were.

As long as that information if any extracted is not part of a trial I see no issues in gathering it. They got a break catching one of them alive. To throw that away would be negligent in my opinion.

This is more of a war type situation than what the general population are used to. The differance if any is that the general population are the target. Economicaly these events are very expensive as well. If repedative they reduce a feeling of security for many. The financial cost of even attempting to deal with them is also through the roof since 9/11.