Kyle (and Eric, as well): Don't forget the N/A 5-speed manual Subaru Legacy from '90 to '94 with AWD, if you can't find a Sport in decent condition. These cars have some pep and are pretty fun to hammer through corners; the AWD makes them hang on to pavement like barnacles to ship bottoms. (I've driven my friend's '92 Subaru Legacy L wagon a couple times).

-Sam