Well now I'm not sure which pulley to use...

the Pulley on there turns about 1/2 turn when I spin it. (Fenner from the parts store)
The one I took off that is from 2014 Turns like a quarter turn when I spin it. (INA from Pelican parts.)
Both look pretty good.

I guess I'll try it with the one I just cleaned and put back on and if it chirps I'll swap them out.