View Single Post
  #83  
Old 07-30-2004, 07:53 PM
KirkVining's Avatar
KirkVining KirkVining is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 5,303
Quote:
Originally posted by MT_Merc
Kirk, you seem quite knowledgeable regarding American history, and I read your comments on Civil War strategy with interest. I have often thought that what is needed in our war on terror is a modern-day Sherman. But such a commander would not be allowed to prosecute the war as he saw fit, not just yet anyway. It took almost a year for the reality of the Civil War to sink in on both north and south, and I think in many ways the reality of the war on terror has yet to sink in on America in general. It may well take a nuclear or biological strike in which tens, hundreds of thousands, or more, people die, before a clear majority of Americans will be prepared for the measures necessary. I don't know that we can win the war the way we are going; there is not will to do more than we are doing, and the less we do, the more vulnerable we become.
But I digress. I notice one general you did not mention was McClellan. In my mind, McClellan was largely responsible for the Civil War lasting as long as it did. On several different occasions he could have crushed the Confederate army, but instead made excuses for not doing it. As one of his officers suggested, he seemed to be motivated by either cowardice or treason. That or he was easily fooled by the enemy, but he seems to have been smarter than that. He was a brilliant organizer, and he did much to build the Army of the Potomac into a proper army, but he seemed ill-fit to lead, perhaps because of his rapid promotion and resulting egocentric nature.
Clearly, combat tactics and strategery are in continuous development. Find a way to outdo your opponent or you stand a good chance of defeat. Right now I believe that our military and policing agencies are in the process of revamping itself to better deal with terrorist threats. It is taking time, and perhaps longer than it should, but I believe it is happening. It is now clear that our years of planning for fighting Communist Russia left us unprepared to fight the current terrorist.
I come by the Civil War gig honestly - my maternal grandfather was an antique dealer who was one of the top experts on Civil War artifacts in New Hampshire. Not only was his house a veritible Civil War museum, but the passerbys and visitors were men of the Boston academic circle and wealthy Brahmin collectors, and many a day when I was a boy was passed listening and participating in spirited discussion with very learned men on the subject. In addition my grandfather took a great personal interest in educating my brother, cousins and I on whatever facet of the Civil War we were personally interested in, and each new artifact he acquired garnered our rapt attention as he told us the story of a sword or rifle he acquired. Of such stuff, young boys dreams are built. He spawned a family of expertise in the subject - all of us have had life long hobbies in the area that we share amongst each other. I inherited his book collection, consisting of first hand account books printed right after the war, some letters and a lifetime of historical works on the subject.

I do not personally believe my grandfather was aware the 20th Century had occured. To the very day he passed in the early '80s, he was truly a 19th century man. Portions of his personal collection of Civil War letters have been the subjects of books (if you ever see a copy of "Letters from a Berdan Sharpshooter", that is a picture of my still living grandmother on the back cover) and several other works were dedicated to him. His most remarkable find was a scrimshaw powder horn he picked up a garage sale for $6. The scrimshaw carvings turned out to be a soldiers way of recording what he witnessed at the Battle of Bunker Hill in 1776, and he traced it to its original owner. It was on display at the Harvard Museum until a few years ago, when my grandmother sold it, for a much tidier sum than $6.

In any case, I think Little Mac was good and bad. He was the human display of the fact that some men rise to high places because they become very learned on a particular subject, but at the same time are a disappointment because they lack any original thinking that would allow them to act on that knowledge in a way we would call genius. He knew drill, discipline and spit and polish to the last dotted i. As such, at the beginning of the war he achieved success over the rag tag enemy he faced, and rose rapidly to the top as a result. But he did not rise because of brillaint tactics, he rose because his men had been trained to fight Napoleonically very well, and could therefore deliver organized and sustained firepower better than the barefoot southerns he first faced. IN the end, this became the good, because as General Commanding of the Army of the Potomac, he took a totally undisciplined and unorganized draftee and immigrant enlistee army, and drilled and trained them into a formidable fighting machine, albeit one that would subsequently become poorly used.

Like many men of limited intelligence, and well exemplified by our current president, when he rose to high office while simultaneously being adulated and worshipped by those around him, he became infected with hubris and arrogance to the point it affected his mind, however with McClellan it also came with a little voice deep down inside that told him to fear and exaggerate the unknown. His unknown was Robert E. Lee's army, which he was convinced was twice as large as his. But his fear was not that of a coward, I believe it was the fear of a man who will not drive a beautiful car because he was afraid he might scratch it, to the point he is afraid to walk out of the house. In a way you have to sympathize with him - he started with a mob of insubordinate louts who took off running at 1st Bull Run, and turned them into this superbly drilled and uniformed fighting machine - it is said he spent days at a time simply watching them march, gazing in wonderment at his own great handiwork. So for years he pulled his punches in battle so his car would stay pretty. When he finally did fully committ himself, at Antietam, he almost ended the Civil War, but once again hestitation and indecision ruined the day. Maybe he might of matured in the job, but I doubt it.

Your observation on us entering a new age is agreed to by me. The new war paradigm is war carried on by clandestine means on a very personal basis, which is why I have always felt the Bush war of occupation was not only stupid, but betrayed an ulterior motive to his actions. In this day and age, a European Cold War style conflict is a ridiculous idea. Terrorists don't flock to some country to get killed - they are mobile and trans-national, and they are wired. They metastisize like cancer - their overall plan is complex and known only to them, and is achieved by sinking small tenticles and roots into the society they wish to inflict themselves on. Their meticulous planning is geared to achieve enormous results for efforts that may take years. Like any octupus, the cure for being strangled by the tenticles is to hunt down and destroy the head, which is why I am outraged we did not spend every conceivable effort to hunt this man down.

We need to convert about 500,000 of our military personal to Special Forces units, and send them out into the world to develop our own complex networks to counter these guys. It requires a total rethinking of how to train a soldier - we need soldiers who are not trained to carry 150lbs of gear, but instead are trained in how to speak Arabic or Farsi, and how to melt into a foriegn culture. We don't need big tanks, we need small remote controlled computer devices that can run face recognition patterns , tap databases and direct drone airplanes to identify and kill the enemy. Sherman would have understood.

Last edited by KirkVining; 07-30-2004 at 08:20 PM.
Reply With Quote