Just replace the entire cap at first and the purchase an extra seal or two...

The cap is plastic and I know that nobody has probably had an oil cap blow up like a coolant cap, but it is so cheap and the new one comes with a gasket!

__________________
2006 BMW M5 "Heidi" @ 109,000 miles
2005 MBZ C55 AMG "Lorelai" @ 165,000 miles
1991 MBZ 300E "Benzachino II" @ 165,000 miles
1990 MBZ 500SL "Shoshanna" @ 118,000 miles

(On the hunt for a good used M103 engine as of 6/10/23, PM me if you have one to sell!)