Buy a whole new starter. My car did the same when I bought it, hence its cheapness.

Where I got mine loacally set me back $135. Bosch. I'll never have to worry about a starter again. (Uhm... I dont plan on keeping the car long enough to burn through another starter!)

__________________
1974 240 D (4 spd!)
1980 Olsmobile Cutlass Supreme Brougham 350-DIESEL
1969 VW Bus
1964 Chevy Pickup, severly Kustom... SOLD!
'69 Yamaha AT-1, '71 CB350, '79 XS1100
'81 XS650, '82 XJ650, '83 GR650
'83 KZ1100, '88 GSX600, '03 RSX-S
http://burndup.kicks-ass.net
http://www.dieselhoopty.com