Racism and the Brain - PeachParts Mercedes-Benz Forum

Kuan · #1 11-29-2004, 07:17 AM

I read this article a few days ago. The study suggests that racism is hardwired, but also that our rational side can overcome racism. Here is an excerpt:

Quote:

Evidence that we are wired for racism comes from studies in which whites were shown pictures of black faces. That typically produced a spike in activity in the part of the brain, called the amygdala, that is the source of wariness and vigilance, responding automatically and emotionally to possible threats. The greater the whites' negative attitude toward blacks, as measured on the unconscious-stereotyping test, the greater the activity in the amygdala when they saw black faces, compared with the activity when they saw white ones. (Data from studies in which blacks saw white faces are less clear-cut.)

But that primitive response is not inevitable. In a new study, researchers found that it indeed occurred when the faces were flashed for 30 milliseconds, so quickly that they could be seen only subconsciously. There was no such difference in amygdala activity, however, when the white volunteers saw faces for 525 milliseconds, scientists led by William Cunningham of the University of Toronto will report next month in the journal Psychological Science.

Instead, there was greater activity in the prefrontal cortex and the anterior cingulate. Both regions are associated with higher thought and with inhibition and control of reflexive responses. This suggests that the thoughtful, rational part of the brain snuffed out the prejudicial response that would have otherwise popped up from the amygdala. In fact, people who showed the most unconscious bias on the test of unconscious stereotyping, and thus had the most to control, also showed the greatest activation of higher brain functions when they saw black faces.

"If people have a chance, they can modify or override the emotional response with the cognitive regions of their brain," says Prof. Cunningham.

Although you might think that racism is fundamental and inevitable because it emanates from a primitive part of the brain, even if we can override it with a higher region, Prof. Cunningham demurs: "It's silly to say that these automatic reactions are the true you," or that they are any more "you" than thoughtful reactions that reflect consciousness and beliefs.

Consider what happened when white volunteers looked at yearbook photos of black or white faces for two seconds to determine any of three things: if they were over 21, if there was a dot on the face, or if the person depicted looked as if he or she liked a particular vegetable.

There was no extra activity in the amygdala when the whites looked for a dot on a black face, found psychologist Susan Fiske of Princeton University. They were probably seeing the faces not as faces but as mere background for a dot, so no racist feelings surfaced. But there was a spike in amygdala activity when the whites scrutinized the black faces to assess age. Categorizing someone for one purpose (age) seemed to activate stereotypes of another category (race).

But then the volunteers looked at black faces to assess their affinity for asparagus (or celery, or carrots). There was no amygdala spike. Why? This task forced the volunteers to see black faces as those of unique individuals. That inhibited what Prof. Fiske calls "category-based emotional responses" generated by the amygdala.

Full articel here:

http://www.beliefnet.com/story/156/story_15664_1.html

boneheaddoctor · #2 11-29-2004, 09:08 AM

Psuedo science can show proof of anything.

Including space aliens.

I contend racism is a learned behaviour, not one you are born to.

Otherwise explain Blacks racism to Asians, and Jews, Arabs towards everyone else, Some blacks towards whites.....

Racism has no bearing on what race you were born into........but it has everything to do with learned responses from family and friends.

I was raised to see people for who they are not what color their skin is.

kerry · #3 11-29-2004, 09:54 AM

It would be interesting to know what other things stimulate a similar response. Would predatory animals cause the same thing? Would people of the same race dressed certain ways cause the same response? Do women respond differently than men? Would Democrats respond the same way to a picture of Bush? Do teenagers respond the same way as adults? Do people raised in societies with different socialization processes for morality respond differently?

KirkVining · #4 11-29-2004, 03:40 PM

IMO, all humans have a tribal instinct and instinctual fear of strangers which we acquired early in our evolution, that is counteracted by cognitive functions acquired later in our evolution. Genes in either area can dominate depending on the individual, and can be repressed or reinforced through education or socialization. Certain groups may have more predominant instinctual genes, like White Northern Europeans or Equatorial Africans. Racism is not a learned behavior, it is an instinct that can be reinforced through socialization as a racist.

jjl · #5 11-29-2004, 04:10 PM

Twin studies needed here. Phenotype = genotype x environment...

jjl · #6 11-29-2004, 06:40 PM

You got it.