Laso or Graf Coolant pump for my C230?

[blackmercedes]

I see that there are two different water pumps for my C230 (M111.974) and was wondering if one was better than the other? In Canada, the Laso can be had for $196 and the Graf is $127. The dealer wants $309.00 for whatever one they have (I assume it's one of those) so I'd like to buy from a third-party supplier.

[anthonyb]

From what I've read here, anecdotally the Laso is supposed to be a better brand. I put in a Laso in mine last year, and so far it's working fine.

i agree, use the laso brand pump

[blackmercedes]

Thanks!!

[mbdoc]

Both are Italian castings! The Graf uses the "OE" bearing & seal assembly made by INA..

Graf owns over 50% of Laso!

[deanyel]

Originally Posted by M.B.DOC

Both are Italian castings! The Graf uses the "OE" bearing & seal assembly made by INA..

Graf owns over 50% of Laso!

So you would consider them equilvelents? Laso always has the higher price - and so many people equate that with quality when it often isn't so.

[mbdoc]

Graf is THE best aftermarket pump for MB!

Warranty failure rate is less than 0.05%

[sokoloff]

What pump comes with the star on it?

Len

[Secret Squirrel]

Originally Posted by M.B.DOC

Graf is THE best aftermarket pump for MB!

Warranty failure rate is less than 0.05%

Good, now I'm happy the worldpac place I ordered from shipped me a Graf even though I ordered the Laso

[erubin]

Maybe the important choice is to use MB coolant or at least avoid the coolants with silicates (see ingredients on the jug). I wonder if the silicates accelerate the wear of the water pump bearing?