Hey guys, I broke the hose from the valve cover to the oil separator (I believe) while working on my car. I had a very hard time finding a hose the style that was on my car, this style:


So I looked around and found this style:


I read many threads and supposedly one is an updated version of the other, but the question is which is which? I couldn't tell, some say the metal one is better, others the rubber, I know I need one rather than just venting to the atmosphere

Thanks,
Mike w.

__________________
1984 300sd auto with 246,000 miles