I have the old piece but it is much the worse for wear. I fixed the pass. side with some Masonite and it looks nearly new but I thought if I could find one for $10-20 I would replace the driver's sode rather than build a new one. My only concern is that the driver's side has what appears to be a compound curve in it which might be difficult to replacate in 1/8" hardboard. But, since this is to be my son's car and not open to auto show type scrutiny I think the Masonite might be as good as any.